On this episode, we’re zooming out, tracing how nearly four decades of federalism, landmark statutes like the 1984 Sentencing Reform Act, and a public appetite for tougher penalties have pushed federal and state sentencing systems down increasingly different paths. Those contrasts aren’t just academic; they reveal the collective choices we’ve made, sometimes consciously, sometimes in the heat of political moments, about who deserves mercy and who merits the maximum.

We’ll also examine why the patchwork of state sex-offense registries looks the way it does. State sovereignty, legacy bureaucracies, fear-driven politics, and voter priorities all play a part, so real reform will demand a mix of public education, strategic litigation, and, ultimately, ballot-box accountability.

And we’ll cap things off with a breaking New York Court of Appeals decision: federal sex-crime convictions can’t automatically tag someone as a “sexually violent offender” in New York because there’s no federal registry to mirror. Albany legislators are already drafting a fix, but for now, the ruling opens a brief, and important, window in the Empire State.

[03:02] Federal vs. State Sentences: Why the Huge Disparity?
[13:33] Why Harsh Registry Laws Persist—and What We Can Do
[23:10] Sherlock Without Holmes: The Court’s Surprising Decision
[40:00] When Mob Rule Cancels the Mic: Free Speech Under Fire

https://www.registrymatters.co/podcast/rm345-debunking-the-federal-registry-myth-new-york-court-speaks/
Email us: registrymatterscast@gmail.com
Leave an old fashioned voice message: 747 227-4477 
Support us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/registrymatters
Join the Discord server: https://discord.gg/6FnxwAQm57
Want to support Registry Matters with some swag:
https://fypeducation.org/shop/
Apple Podcasts: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/registry-matters/id1305039280
RSS: https://www.registrymatters.co/feed/podcast/
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/3d75P7Kc37n2l79m89F9KI
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/registrymatters

The Registry Matters Podcast’s mission is to cover issues surrounding the Registry. We cover cases that will peel back the veneer of what we need to do to change our lives for the better. We cover news articles that spark conversations about the total insanity of this modern day witch hunt. This podcast will call out bad policy and call out those that are making bad policy.

To change things for the positive, we need to act. We are 6-7-8-900k strong. With that many people, plus their friends and family, over a million people are affected by the registry. We should be able to secure donations to hire lawyers and lobbyists to move the agenda in our favor. We need our people to be